Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Monday, January 3, 2011

What's Up With the Girls in Harry Potter? Hormonal Hermione & Other Thoughts


I understand it's "JK," not Joanne Kathleen, because publishers thought boys wouldn't read a book written by a woman. I'm not sure if that's legend or not, but I'm pretty sure I heard it somewhere in this excellent interview with Oprah, one that made me want to be JK's best friend AND live in that hotel in Edinburgh where JK writes.

So in this context, perhaps it's not surprising that boys dominate the story and very well should, if Harry is the star. There's no literary law that says stories must promote girls to equal face time. I refuse to demand that of Rowling's work. But I am interested in the female roles.

At one point I put down Book Three and thought, "Wow, Hermione's pretty hormonal." That conclusion made me nervous, so I thought I might need to examine the female characters more closely.

If we take Hermione Granger and Professor Minerva McGonagall as key females in the series (and keep in mind, I've only read through book three), I might draw these conclusions:

-- Girls are incredibly smart. Hermione is the smartest one at Hogwarts and rarely without the answer.

-- Girls follow the rules. Hermione is the first to list them and tell Harry and Ron not to break them, and Professor McGonagall often catches the boys at breaking them.

-- Girls study hard. We don't have to say much more than "Book Three" and Hermione taking almost every class available with a special time-traveler trick.

-- Girls spoil the fun. Harry and Ron often avoid her since she's a reminder of the rules and gets so mad when the boys break them.

-- Girls serve as secondary characters. Or tertiary, especially in Quidditch. Is there any reason a girl can't be a team captain, or is it just too much rugby on broomsticks? Though women do play rugby...)

-- Girls get tearful and moody. A lot. Especially when they're taking every class available while trying to reprimand their two best guy friends. Hermione remains pretty much a wreck through a good section of Book Three, after a seemingly tragic scuffle between Scabbers and Crookshanks. And I love Professor McGonagall but she's a grump.

-- Girls are brave. Hermione is not afraid of facing adventure when she deems it necessary. She even breaks a few rules for the sake of friendship. Without her knowledge, Harry and she can't save Lupin, Buckbeak, and others in Book Three.

I really like Hermione's defiance of Professor Trelawney in Book Three. By laughing in the face of mysticism and fortune telling (stereotypically the domain of women), she breaks the stereotype of women being "intuitive." When she misbehaves in Trelawney's class, it's refreshing and real in the sense that Hermione distinguishes herself as not just a teacher's pet, not just a rule-abiding nerd, but as a more unique, complicated teen.

I'm in the eighties of Book Four and so far, it's the Quidditch World Cup and a lot of boy stuff (if we're staying true to stereotype--sports, tents, high jinks, etc.). Hermione's a shadow of herself thus far and I miss her.

I can't say I'm impressed with the female roles, but I can't say I'm disappointed, either. I love the series enough to realize I shouldn't expect it to be all things to all people. And Hermione isn't really a candidate for hormone therapy; her moods aren't any worse than Ron's. She just cries more.

What do you think? Would you write in some new females for Harry Potter, anywhere in the first few books? Would you write in new actions or character traits for Hermione? Or is the Harry Potter series just right as it is?

Saturday, January 1, 2011

What We Did Right This Year


Last night across America, millions of people who’d never met and may not have ever wanted to meet turned to a stranger and said, “So, what do you do?”

I have no doubt some of these folks had an uproariously good time, but little did they know this question works like torture not only in these economic times but pretty much any time at all.

“Do” means “Give me your stats.” Your income, your résumé highlights, your impressive numbers. "Do" boils us down to concrete, financially-viable actions taken and monetary results achieved. What do you do? never means, Tell me who you are, tell me what you value, tell me what you love.

I think a better question for the New Year is, "What did you do right this past year? What didn't make the billboards, Twitter, Facebook status, or Google Alerts?"

Forget feverish revolution and anxious browbeating. Let's not spend the first day of 2011 with to-do lists. Let's make it a Sabbath from the shoulds, the musts, the wills.

For writers, it is tempting to berate ourselves with the stats not yet achieved: agents not landed, contracts not signed, and manuscripts not done. To feel that our pages and publications number too little to be noticed; to feel sad that our writing practice lacks the perfect devotion of a triathlete, a marathoner, a special ops soldier. Always there is someone far more devoted, persistent, and perfectly successful out there. They must never cease working, these dynamos. If only you had resolve, you, too, could be they...I like Hope Clark's wisdom about having never arrived on this writer's journey. The work never ceases for any of us, and it's a delusion to think all the others who have success are "already there."

This last year I became more patient with what I once deemed lack of progress. At my day job I keep an African proverb by my desk: "If you want to go fast, walk alone. If you want to go far, walk together." I used to think certain people and situations stymied me. I now know they're here for good reason, and on the worst days, if for nothing else, for short-story fodder. At my writing job (which is also every day), I keep many quotations, but these catch my eye today:

"We've got to measure goodness by what we embrace, what we create, and who we include." Hugh O'Connor

"Bide your time, for success is near." Fortune Cookie. (For all local North Carolinians, you must try the wonderful Gourmet Kingdom where this fortune was found.)

When I write I ask myself if what I'm writing I love and believe in, if my writing brings me and others good, and if I am making time for people as much as my pages.

This last year I set my mind on higher things. I listened to the quiet while driving in my car. I listened to the wisdom of spiritual guides and read sacred texts. And I asked myself sometimes before I spoke, but most often after: Is this how I wish to speak? Sound? Be?

My family can tell you I sound much wiser here than I do in person, but, I would like some credit for thinking right every once in a while.

No one puts these details on a résumé or in a query letter. It's the kind of do we refrain from sharing with strangers.

I had a moment wondering if "do right" is proper grammar. Upon further review, I determined I mean "right" this way "uprightly or righteously." That's more than correct--that's right good grammar.

It's all good, as they say down here in the South, if what you do is not about racking up the stats but about expressing who you are.

Writing Prompts for Students:

-- What did you do well this past year? How did you know you did well?
-- What did you do right? How do you know?
-- Describe a person you admire greatly for doing things that are true to self. By "true to self," we mean, doing what is honest, right, and good.
-- What did you do that was true to yourself?
-- What did you not do this past year that leaves you feeling discouraged? Why?
-- Make a resolution about how you will think differently this year. Do not resolve to do this or do that, but instead, describe the types of thoughts you wish to have going forward.

Writing Prompts for Teachers:

-- Describe a moment from teaching last year that leaves you smiling. What makes you feel joy or amusement?
-- If there is one thing you do right in your teaching, what is it?
-- Write a paragraph of your thoughts for 2011. This paragraph should be the thoughts you wish to wake up to every morning.
-- What in teaching most discourages you? How will you try to think differently about it this year?
-- Who is a teacher, author, or some other person you admire greatly? Write about not only the concrete accomplishments but the intangibles of character that you value so much.